3D Learning Hub
See all categories

PLA vs ABS: Which 3D Printing Filaments Should You Choose

Introduction

When it comes to 3D printing, choosing the best filament is vital. In this article, we will discuss PLA vs ABS filaments. Understanding the similarities and differences between them will allow you to make the best choice for your project.

There are several printing filaments to choose from for your projects. While it may seem difficult to decide on what is best for you, this article will help you make the best decision. The two most popular materials are ABS or Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene, and PLA, which stands for Polylactic Acid.

FDM printers add materials layer by layer according to your 3D design. It is the most popular additive manufacturing technology and an excellent choice for prototyping. It is also a great choice for the series production of functional parts. With FLM, you have the option to print a diverse range of materials, including plastic or metal components. In this article, we will compare and contrast the benefits of PLA vs ABS.

While both of these are thermoplastics, each has its advantages over the other. Both filaments have a soft, moldable state when heated and return to a solid state when cooled. But PLA is stronger than ABS, while ABS filaments make more durable and lighter products. We will first look at each printing filament in detail before we compare their uses.

Polylactic Acid - PLA

Printing with PLA filaments

Polylactic Acid filaments are the most popular choice for FDM printing. PLA is a vegetable-based plastic material. This makes it more of an environmentally friendly choice over other options. You can derive PLA from renewable natural resources such as cornstarch or sugarcane. As one of the easiest materials to use for 3D printing, PLA allows for a wide range of applications.

The PLA plastic starts out on a large spool that feeds into the printer as needed. When melted, the nozzle extrudes the plastic to form your model. This makes it the most popular choice for beginners in 3D printing, as you can develop rapid prototypes at a low cost.

At Sculpteo, we use this process for a wide range of applications. With a large 3D printer, we use 3Dp BigRep PLA, which is ideal for industrial production. 3Dp BigRep PLA produces perfect prototypes, tool parts, and end-use products. But as with most materials, there are advantages and disadvantages to using PLA filaments.

Pros and cons of using PLA

As mentioned earlier, PLA is a more environmentally friendly filament, making it a popular choice for printing. Choosing materials made from renewable and biodegradable resources is an attractive option. But the main benefit of choosing PLA is its ease of use. You do not need to heat the printing bed as it requires a lower printing temperature than other filaments. PLA allows you to print professional and industrial parts of 1m x 1m x 1m with a high resolution.

But there are also some disadvantages to choosing PLA. Finding the right temperature is vital to ensure you get the required tensile strength. Too low of a temperature will hinder the adhesion of the layers. Too high, and the extruder will leak material causing strings to appear. And PLA also has a lower strength and durability compared to ABS or Nylon.

PLA components will also become brittle over time if exposed to sunlight and high temperature. This can cause the component to crack or break. For this reason, PLA is unsuitable for applications with high humidity. For example, if you experience humidity above 98% or temperatures above 60°C, PLA is not the best option.

Examples of projects best suited for PLA

Sculpteo offers three options for your FDM Printing: PLA, Ultrafuse® 316L, and Ultrafuse® 17-4. As a more eco-friendly material, PLA is a great choice to show awareness from your end. Petroleum-based thermoplastics can take hundreds of years to break down, while PLA will naturally break down in a few years. As a result, you get a durable, strong product, while caring for the environment.

Food packaging is a good example of an industry that benefits from PLA. The packaging can be disposed of easily without harming the environment. And many of your household appliances use PLA material for that same reason. It is the perfect choice if you care about look and form.

So if your project requires a certain aesthetic look rather than high durability, PLA is a great option. You can choose from a wide variety of colors to get the best-looking part. We also offer post-processing options such as chemical smoothing and painting to finish your parts. Whether you require rapid prototypes, accurate models, or containers and molds, PLA should be your first choice.

Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene - ABS

Printing with ABS filaments

ABS or Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene is another common thermoplastic polymer. As the name suggests, it consists of

 Acrylonitrile, Butadiene and Styrene polymers. Many of the characteristics of ABS are similar to the characteristics of PLA. It is compatible to use with a desktop 3D printer, making it popular with beginners. But it does require more effort to use ABS over PLA.

ABS is lightweight, but it has a high tensile strength. It can handle impacts well and is relatively resistant to abrasion. Its price is affordable for most projects, and ABS polymers can withstand many chemical formulas. You also get a high-quality surface finish that is flame-retardant. These factors make it a suitable filament for many household appliances.

Overall, ABS is quite versatile, and there are certain instances where it is the best choice. But there are also concerns about the toxicity of the ABS material when it reaches its melting point. ABS is known to emit fumes when it exits the extrusion head, and there can be quite a strong smell at its melting temperature.

Pros and cons of using ABS

One of the main benefits of using ABS is its strength and durability. ABS can withstand more stress and impact than PLA prints. That makes it a good option for functional parts and prototypes. But ABS will shrink as it cools, so printing requires a heated bed to prevent warping and cracking.

ALso, ABS has a higher melting point when compared to PLA, so it needs to be printed at a higher temperature. So ABS is ultimately more complex to print than PLA. But in turn, this also makes ABS more heat resistant, making it a good choice if your product will encounter heat. A good example would be the handles on a saucepan.

This higher glass transition temperature means the extruder requires a temperature in the 210-250°C range. It is considerably more challenging to work with, especially for beginners. And you must be aware of the smell and fumes when you print with ABS. Take care to use it in a well-ventilated area and take appropriate precautions.

Examples of projects best suited for ABS

So what are the ideal products for ABS plastic? There are several application possibilities for plastic manufacturing with ABS. But many of them are also possible with PLA. In fact, for most uses, you will not see a major difference between PLA and ABS. So at Sculpteo, we offer PLA printing as opposed to ABS. But there are some applications where ABS may be more suitable.

With the lighter weight of ABS, vehicles can decrease their overall weight. This can make them more fuel efficient and more cost-effective to the consumer. But the extra energy required to print ABS makes the price more expensive for the manufacturer. But ABS would be a good choice here with its strong finish that will not scratch easily.

And just like PLA, ABS is an ideal material to manufacture low-cost prototypes. ABS is also one of the more popular plastics to use for constructing vacuum parts. Again, the durable finish can come in many colors and withstand heavy use. Similarly, many plastic medical prostheses are manufactured using ABS material.

PLA

Comparing PLA vs ABS

Differences in surface finishing

A key difference between PLA and ABS is their surface finishing. PLA yields more of a smooth and shiny surface finish compared to ABS. But PLA can also be more prone to stringing. That can affect the quality of the surface finish. But with light sanding, these objects can still end up with a polished and professional appearance.

On the other hand, ABS has a more textured and matte surface finish than PLA. However this may not be as visually appealing as PLA’s smoother finish. But, in return, ABS is more resistant to scratches and wear and tear. That can hide imperfections and make objects look more natural. This makes it a good choice for objects that will be handled often.

Heat resistance properties

When you look at the heat resistance properties, ABS is generally more heat-resistant than PLA. But both PLA and ABS have their limits when it comes to heat resistance. ABS has a glass transition temperature of around 105°C, while with PLA, it is in the 60°C range. So PLA will be more prone to melting or softening at lower temperatures than ABS. However, ABS will still deform if exposed to temperatures that are too high.

The best conclusion to take from this, is that PLA may be a suitable option if the component will only experience moderate temperatures. But if the component will experience high temperatures, ABS may be the better choice. However, you also need to factor in the strength and the surface finish that you require. Ultimately the specific application of the component may sway your choice.

Strength of PLA vs ABS

The tensile strengths of PLA and ABS objects are actually quite similar. ABS is generally considered to be more durable and flexible than PLA. It also has a higher impact resistance and can withstand higher levels of stress and strain than PLA. And ABS is also less brittle than PLA, which means that it is less likely to crack or break under stress.

But PLA has good tensile strength and is resistant to deformation under load. It is more rigid and will maintain its shape better when put under stress. So if rigidity is important to your component, PLA may be the more suitable option. But again, you need to consider the heat resistance properties and required surface finish before making a final choice. If you simply need a fast prototype, PLA is a great choice since in this case, form is more important than function.

How Sculpteo Can Help You Choose Between PLA vs ABS

Choosing Sculteo’s online 3D printing service for your 3D printing will offer several benefits over doing it yourself. Our high-quality printers and materials produce consistent and accurate components. While printing one-off components is possible on a desktop printer, the trial and error involved can be difficult if you are a beginner.

Our team of experts can offer guidance and advice to help ensure that your products meet your specific needs. This saves you time that can be better used in the marketing and management of your products. Whether you need a rapid prototype to showcase your ideas or a series of parts, we are here to help you.

Our design team will help advise on the best 3D printing filament for your project. So get in touch today and choose the best materials for your next printing projec

Get the latest 3D printing news delivered right to your inbox

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter to hear about the latest 3D printing technologies, applications, materials, and software.